Why I Removed My Cookie Opt In Box

cookie opt in eatenThe UK Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations finally came into force on 26th May to much confusion (not to mention snarling and gnashing of teeth).  Known as the Cookie Law, it actually applies to all tracking online.

Controlling tracking sounds like a great idea doesn’t it.  Protect our privacy and all that.

But, cookies aren’t bad, evil or even affect our privacy for the most part.  Businesses online need cookies.  

From analytics to social sharing to shopping carts – all these features need some form of tracking information to work.  They don’t take down your name, address and date of birth and send them to some criminal underworld to have your identity stolen.  They just make everything work and allow businesses to measure what is going on with their website.

Some cookies that are necessary to make a website work – like shopping carts – are exempt.  However, essential cookies for running a business online – your analytics – are not.

A Cookie Opt In?

The new cookie rule meant website owners need to ask permission to drop cookies on visitors’ computers.

At the eleventh hour the ICO changed their mind about how the rule could be implemented.  Implied consent is now Ok – they said that the day before the rule was implemented.   

If they were clear right at the very beginning most of us would have just said, “These are the cookies used on my website, it’s up to you the viewer to block them if you choose.”  That would have been that, no headaches, no wasted time, and for some businesses no small fortunes spent implementing cookie controls.

Cookie Opt In Pitfalls

Deep down, I like rules.  I’m comfortable working within guidelines, you know where you stand (although, it’s true if I don’t like where I am standing I tend to kick up a bit of a fuss!)  So, I left my cookie opt in box on till now, while I measure the impact.

But, I am also a business.  Without measuring how my website is doing, I have no way of improving it or removing things that don’t work.

cookie opt in fail

Analytics became useless under the new Cookie Law

Cookie optin was definitely not working for me.  My analytics were useless.

I knew how many people came to the site, and where they came from.  Useful info like how long people stayed and whether they clicked through to other pages suddenly disappeared.

My bounce rate shot up to 96% – a bounce is when people click on your website and then leave again without viewing any other pages. 

Average time on site dropped to 13 seconds and 97% of my visitors were “new” visitors.

What was I doing wrong?!

Actually, nothing.  What the numbers do tell me is when given the choice to opt in to cookies, most people ignore the request.  No surprises there then, that’s human nature.

So, the cookie opt in has gone.  I can’t work blind.  

For those of you who are seriously concerned about cookies, you can turn them off in your browser.  All About Cookies has instructions for most browsers. 

You can find details of the cookies used on this website in the privacy policy too.  There’s nothing extreme – Google Analytics, social sharing, YouTube, my email optin and of course WordPress session cookies because this website runs on WordPress.

What are your thoughts on the Cookie Law?  Have you made steps towards implementation?  Your comments are welcome below.

Cookie Monster via Flickr Graph image from Cobrasoft

Stay Up To Date

If you liked this this article, get email updates and help yourself to a heap of free local online marketing resources. Simply leave your details below in the box, click the button... and let me take care of the rest:

Comments

  1. Hi Jan
    So what are the actual rules re cookies and are there cookie police looking for the rule breakers – I don’t get it? But I am sure you will explain – simply please – I’ve never got cookies!
    Sue
    Sue Worthington recently posted..New Facebook WordPress PluginMy Profile

  2. Ooh! the Cookie Police! That sounds like an interesting organisation Sue Worthington! Do they go soggy if left out of the tin!
    To be serious for a moment, like you Jan have just added to our Privacy Policy. -Caroline

  3. Hi Jan,

    Thank you for such an educational article. From my personal experience of using websites since 26 May, I have never been asked for a permission by any of these websites to store cookies on my computer. Is it just that nobody is doing it, or am I missing something? I have been told that simply placing a visible note on your site that your website is using cookies is sufficient. But from the quoted document it does not look like it, and it is worrying. Will try to read more about it to see how others are keeping up with the law. Great post!

    Kind wishes,

    Galina
    Galina St george recently posted..EVEN MORE ABOUT PRODUCT CREATIONMy Profile

  4. Well said Jan. I’m not doing anything till I know more otherwise I’m sure I’ll make things worse!

Speak Your Mind

*

CommentLuv badge

  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest